More than just great meat.

We carry a large selection of frozen seafood, from lobster tails and scallops to salmon, walleye, and Chilean sea bass. Whether you're building a Surf & Turf dinner or you're a dedicated fish eater, we have you covered with high-quality, affordable options.

Do you prefer fresh seafood or are you looking for something a bit hard to find?

We can special-order just about any seafood item through our network of fishmongers at competitive pricing!

Why We Love Frozen Seafood

Most "fresh" fish at grocery stores was frozen and thawed before it hit the case. Our frozen seafood skips that step — and that's actually a good thing.

Peak Freshness
Our seafood is flash-frozen at the peak of freshness, often right on the boat or at the dock. You're getting fish at its best, not fish that spent days traveling to a store.
Better Variety
Frozen lets us stock seafood from around the world year-round. Canadian lobster, Norwegian salmon, Alaskan halibut, Chilean sea bass, all available whenever you want them, not just when they're in season nearby.
Better for the Planet
Frozen seafood doesn't require extra trips from boat to shore or expedited air freight. The more sustainable transport model is better for the environment...and helps keep your prices lower too!
Packaged shrimp with blue and orange branding on a crowded shelf.

What We Carry

Our selection is always evolving, but here's what you'll typically find in our freezer:

  • Canadian Lobster Tails
  • A variety of shrimp - cooked and raw, jumbo and large, wild caught and farm raised.
  • Scallops
  • Cod
  • Salmon
  • Tuna
  • Walleye
  • Alaskan Halibut
  • Mahi Mahi
  • Tilapia
  • Swordfish
  • And more!

    Stop in to see what's available!
Two fish in a container of ice

Special Orders

Can't find what you're looking for? We can source just about any seafood item, fresh or frozen, at competitive pricing.

  1. Call us at 262-248-3339 (option 3) at least 5 days before you need it. Not sure on details? We'll help you figure it out.
  2. We'll reach out to our fishmongers and get you a quote. No commitment required.
  3. If you like the price, we'll order it. Pick up in store, usually within 2 days.

Many of our customers take advantage of this no-pressure process, so try it yourself!

Common Questions

Is frozen seafood really as good as fresh?

In most cases, yes — and often better. Most "fresh" seafood at grocery stores was previously frozen and thawed for display. Our seafood stays frozen from catch to your kitchen, so it's locked in at peak quality. You thaw it when you're ready to cook, not when the store decides to put it out.

Do you carry fresh seafood?

Due to the short shelf life and high waste rates of fresh seafood, we do not carry fresh seafood, but we can special order fresh seafood for you at very competitive rates.

Call us at 262-248-3339 (option 3) at least 5 days in advance and we'll get you a quote. We can source almost anything.

Is your seafood sustainably sourced?

We carry a large amount of sustainably sourced seafood and prioritize purchasing from sustainable fisheries whenever possible. We believe in responsible sourcing and work with suppliers who share that commitment.

How far in advance do I need to place a special order?

Give us at least 5 days' notice. We'll get a quote from our fish mongers — if you like the price, your order is usually ready for pickup within 2 days. No commitment if the price doesn't work for you.

Three cardboard boxes labeled 'Oishii Shrimp' and 'Royal Eagle Argentina Red Shrimp' stacked on a wooden floor.

Ready to get cooking?

Stop in to browse our freezer selection, or call to place a special order. Our Meat Ambassadors are happy to help.

Visit Our Market