Thanksgiving at Lake Geneva Country Meats

Thanksgiving orders are still open.

Our turkeys are sold out. We’re still taking orders for other meats, deli sides, and everyday favorites.

Still hoping for a turkey? Join the waitlist through the form below. A waitlist request does not reserve or guarantee a turkey.

Order meats & sides Join the turkey waitlist
Roast turkey, stuffing, gravy and vegetables ready to share around a Thanksgiving table
Already reserved a turkey? Your confirmed reservation remains in place. No need to join the waitlist or order again.
Pickup November 19–28 Use this form for all pickup orders during these dates. Closed Thanksgiving Day, November 26.
Order now. Pay at pickup. Other meats, deli sides, and everyday orders are still welcome.

Reserve online. Pick up in store.

Place your Thanksgiving pickup order.

Use this form for all pickup orders November 19–28, including everyday orders. Pay when you pick up.

Ordering meats or sides? Leave the turkey selection empty and choose Continue to Other Meats.

Joining the turkey waitlist? Select an option marked Waitlist Only, then choose Add to Turkey Waitlist and finish the form. A waitlist request does not guarantee a turkey.

We’ll see you at Country Meats

Pickup made simple.

When you arrive to pick up your order, take a number. When it's your turn, tell your Meat Ambassador the name of the person listed for pickup.

We'll get your order for you. Pay the final total, and you'll be on your way to enjoying a fantastic Thanksgiving meal.

5907 State Road 50 East
Lake Geneva, WI 53147

Find us & get in touch

Retail Hours

Monday–Friday
9 AM–6 PM
Saturday
9 AM–3 PM
Sunday
10 AM–2 PM

We are closed Thursday, November 26, for Thanksgiving Day. 

Please note our custom processing department closes at 5 PM on weekdays and is not open on Sunday.

Turkey information

Our turkeys: sold out for new reservations.

These details are here for customers with existing reservations and those considering the turkey waitlist. All turkey options are sold out for new reservations.

Fresh · never frozen

Harrison's Whole Turkey

$4.79/lb

Sold out · Waitlist available

Sourced for us by Harrison's Poultry from USDA-inspected farms in Minnesota, these fresh turkeys are tender and flavorful and come with giblets for stuffing, gravy, and other recipes.

Join the turkey waitlist

For white-meat lovers

Harrison's Bone-In Turkey Breast

$5.49/lb

Sold out · Waitlist available

For smaller groups or groups who do not like dark turkey meat, a bone-in turkey breast is an excellent option. These breasts come from the same USDA-inspected Minnesota farms as our whole turkeys.

Join the turkey waitlist

Pasture-raised · Hyperlocal

Alden Hills Whole Turkey

$7.59/lb

Sold out · Waitlist available

Our Alden Hills Organic Farms turkeys are pasture-raised. Coming to us from Walworth, Wisconsin, these turkeys are extra flavorful and perfect for people who love heirloom turkey flavor.

Join the turkey waitlist

Butchering for your reserved turkey.

These butchering services can help with cooking and serving. To request a change to an existing reservation, use the reservation lookup. Changes are subject to our team’s review:

  • Halving a full turkey: $5
  • Cutting a full turkey into eighths: $10
  • Spatchcocking a turkey: $10
  • Deboning a turkey breast: $10

Request a change to your reservation

Wine for the Thanksgiving table

Nick’s Thanksgiving wine picks

A few bottles I’d put on the Thanksgiving table. Pick your favorite, or mix and match for the meal.

Find these in our wine department when you pick up your order.

Explore our wine department
Weather Pinot Noir

For Red wine lovers

Weather Pinot Noir

$19.99 + tax

This Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir is a perfect wine pairing with turkey and all the fixings. 

Raspberry & strawberry fruit flavors combine with notes of tobacco and baking spice on the smooth finish.

Bottle of Landhaus Mayer Riesling

For white wine lovers

Landhaus Mayer Riesling

$14.99 + tax

Dry Austrian Riesling is a refreshing way to pair wine with all of your Thanksgiving favorites.

Floral aromas are matched by apricot and peach flavors with a crisp, mineral finish.

Cantagrillos Sparkling Wine Bottle

For everyone to enjoy

Cantagrillos Brut

$14.99 + tax

Bubbles are fun for everyone, whether enjoyed as a toast or paired with any food. 

This Spanish sparkling wine has clean flavors of honey and green apples with rich bubbles and a pleasant finish.

Before the big meal

A few good questions.

Still need help? Give us a call.

(262) 248-3339

Are turkeys sold out, and how do I join the waitlist?

Yes, turkeys are sold out for new reservations. In the order form, select a turkey and size marked Waitlist Only, choose Add to Turkey Waitlist, and complete the remaining steps.

A waitlist request does not reserve or guarantee a turkey. You can order other meats and sides through the same form.

I already reserved a turkey. Is my reservation still confirmed?

Yes. The sold-out notice applies to new turkey reservations. Your existing confirmed reservation remains in place; you do not need to join the waitlist or place another order.

Use Find My Reservation to review your order or request a change.

Can I still order other meats, sides, or everyday items?

Yes. Use this form for all pickup orders November 19–28, even if you aren’t ordering a turkey. Leave the turkey selection empty and choose Continue to Other Meats. Skip any category you don’t need.

You can also request unlisted items; availability must be confirmed. We are closed Thanksgiving Day, November 26.

How do I request a change to my order?

Use the order lookup link in your confirmation to request a change, or call us at (262) 248-3339 option 3. A requested change is not confirmed until our team has reviewed it.

When do I pay, and what can I still order?

No payment is collected online; you pay the final total at pickup. Turkey reservations are sold out, but you can join the waitlist and place orders for other meats, deli sides, and everyday items. Items are subject to availability; items sold by weight are priced using their actual weight at pickup.

How much turkey should I allow per person?

Allow about 1 lb per person. Smaller turkeys have proportionally more bone and less meat, so allow a little extra per person for a smaller bird, and a little more if you’d like leftovers.

This guidance can help you plan servings for a reserved turkey or select a waitlist size.

What’s the difference between Harrison’s Turkeys and Alden Hills?

Harrison’s turkeys are fresh, never-frozen Minnesota birds from our year-round poultry supplier. Alden Hills turkeys are pasture-raised in Walworth, Wisconsin, with a richer flavor, and are previously frozen. 

Both are sold out for new reservations. This information can help you with a reserved turkey or a waitlist preference.

When should I pick up, and how long will my turkey keep?

Choose a pickup day close to the day you’ll cook. USDA guidance is generally to refrigerate fresh or thawed turkey at home for 1–2 days before cooking.

USDA turkey storage guidance

Do I need to thaw my turkey?

No - our turkeys are fresh. 

You may find some ice crystals inside the chest cavity. This is because we rinse the turkeys with water as part of preparing them for you to enjoy at home, then chill them to 32 degrees.

Water freezes at this temperature, but the meat stays fresh. Keeping the turkeys as cold as possible without freezing is the best way to maintain quality.

How long should I cook my turkey?

Cooking time varies by bird size and method. For a whole, unstuffed turkey, plan on roughly 13–15 minutes per pound at 325°F. Use a food thermometer to confirm 165°F in the thickest part of the breast and the innermost thigh and wing, away from bone.

Start with our traditional turkey recipe

What temperature means it’s done?

USDA recommends 165°F, checked with a food thermometer in the thickest part of the breast and the innermost thigh and wing, away from bone. If you cook stuffing inside the bird, its center must also reach 165°F.

USDA turkey cooking guidance

Can you cook the turkey for me?

We do not offer pre-cooked turkeys or meals. 

We do offer turkey butchering to make cooking and serving easier. Whole-turkey services are cutting the turkey in half ($5), cutting into eighths ($10), and spatchcocking ($10) per bird. Turkey breast deboning is $10 per breast.

Fresh Food. Friendly People.

There’s more for your Thanksgiving table.

Order meats & sides